|
By the time this page is read, you may not be able to find the perhaps literally incendiary 10-minute Dutch film "Fitna" online. We found it on YouTube, but the original poster, LiveLeak, withdrew it after only one day because, according to a statement the video-sharing Website released last Friday, "we have to place the safety and well-being of our staff above all else." That’s understandable, given the murderous fury unleashed by the Danish cartoons portraying Mohammad. In fact, in a kind of hommage to those cartoons, in "Fitna," a cartoon Mohammad wears a bomb in his turban, which ultimately goes off. Created by extremist Dutch legislator Geert Wilders, "Fitna" — named for an Arabic word whose meanings include "disturbance," "chaos," and "strife"— is a collage of violent Islamic texts, speeches, deeds, and gestures. Passages from the Koran, calling for death to "unbelievers" by gruesome means, are shown and read aloud throughout, interposed with such pitiable, horrifying scenes as the burning, falling towers of the World Trade Center (and the voiced terrors of the people within them); bombs exploding; scarified bodies; the brandishing of swords and knives and exhortations — to applause — to "cut the throats" of Crusaders (i.e., Christians) and Jews. (In fact, one cleric, identified as speaking in Saudi Arabia, says, "Throats are there to be cut.") One tiny girl, clearly coached, tells her unseen Dutch interviewer that Jews are "monkeys and swines." She knows that because Allah said so, in the Koran. What to make of all this? The film is shocking, and we are perversely glad to have had the chance to see what these people feel. (Note that by "these people" we mean only the people onscreen; there is no way to know what "the silent majority" of Muslims feel.) And as advocates of free speech we can only defend its dissemination against those who would suppress it. But the film is clearly provocative, as were the Dutch cartoons. Wilders hates Islam as much as the "Fitna" clerics hate "unbelievers," unapologetically, unrelievedly, and without making distinctions. He is thumbing his nose (or making another, obscene, gesture) at millions of credulous and poorly educated Muslims who must feel shame and rage at what he has wrought. We hope that their rage does not erupt in violence, thereby proving Wilders’ bitter point. RKB
|