Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter

 
font size: +
 

Birthright: A tonic for the Jewish world

 
 
 

A new report out of Brandeis University not only reaffirms the inspirational effects of a Birthright Israel experience, it shows them to be long lasting. The 10-day trip to Israel is open to Jewish18- to 26-year-olds. According to the report, alumni who participated as far back as eight years ago continue to credit the experience with heightening their sense of connection to Israel and the Jewish people. Compared to age-equivalent non-participants, they are more likely to have become strong advocates for Israel, joined a synagogue or congregation, and married a Jew. But while a Birthright trip is limited to young adults, its full potential to energize the larger Jewish world has yet to be tapped.

“Amazing,” “incredible,” “fantastic” are common characterizations by Birthright participants about the experience. In fact, the new study, which was headed by Brandeis Prof. Leonard Saxe, shows that 73 percent of alumni felt the trip had been very much or somewhat “life-changing.” Only 11 percent said it was not at all life-changing, which includes respondents who might have felt this way because they were already committed Jews.

The effects ripple far beyond the circle of participants. Upon return, a participant’s exhilaration often touches parents, grandparents, and anyone else willing to listen. Hearing a Birthright returnee has inspired many a friend and relative to visit Israel. So Birthright is also an indirect promoter of travel to the Jewish state.

Since the program began 10 years ago, 220,000 young Jews have participated, many of whom previously had little connection to Jewish life. Now, as alums continue their journey of Jewish exploration, they often remain in touch with one another and with Israeli soldiers who rode the buses with them. These are not trivial observations in this age of assimilation and otherwise declining support for Israel among young Jews.

The word is out among wannabe participants, who are both eligible and eager. But here’s a sad statistic: This summer, although some 10,000 Jews went on a Birthright trip, 24,000 were turned down because of lack of funds. (Another 10,000 slots will open for the winter trips.) This year’s $80 million budget would need to double in order to match the demand. Given the recession, now is an especially challenging time to call for a large increase in support. But most wait-listed applicants never reapply, which should prompt a sense of urgency.

Of course, a disappointed applicant might later visit Israel under different auspices or otherwise become engaged in Jewish activities. But the distinctive success of Birthright lies in bringing young people together to share the experience at an optimal period in their development. The transition years into adulthood are a time of introspection about identity. Birthright offers young Jews, especially those who previously felt little connection to their heritage, a singular reference point for the rest of their lives. On the evidence, there is no substitute for a Birthright trip, not only because of how it is framed, but when it takes place in a person’s life.

Which leads to two suggestions: First, seek new sources of funding. Since its inception, Birthright trips largely have been funded by major philanthropists, federations, and the Israeli government. The program has been premised on a free, no-strings offer to participants. This noble intention — that every Jewish young adult has a “birthright” to a free educational trip to Israel — has been overtaken by the program’s success. More important than maintaining the purity of the initial premise is to enlarge the pool of availability. Thus, the terms should be amended. Every participant (or family of a participant) should be encouraged to help cover the cost of a slot for a successor applicant. Those unable at this time should commit to a good faith effort in the next few years.

Second, and more important, Birthright has yet to summon the passionate commitment that has been given to other causes such as support for Israel, the campaign for Soviet Jewry, and the rescue of Ethiopian Jews. Birthright, similarly, could become a central purpose in Jewish life. Its ultimate value deserves community-wide consciousness and financial support — from federations, but also from synagogues, educational institutions, and communal organizations.

Even a fraction of one percent above the dues to these institutions, voluntarily dedicated to Birthright, would open slots for thousands more.

From the pulpit, rabbis, lay leaders, and Birthright returnees could emphasize the importance of Birthright and encourage congregants’ support. Congregational and day schools could seek to integrate Birthright with their own student trips. National and local Jewish agencies could offer financial support and create venues for Birthright alums to participate in their organizations’ activities.

A vast increase in the numbers of givers would enhance the sense of community-wide engagement. The goal should be to transform Birthright from its status as a worthy program to an overarching cause. In the process it would also become a bonding experience for the entire Jewish world.

Disclaimer
The views in opinion pieces and letters do not necessarily reflect the views of The Jewish Standard. The comments posted on this Website are solely the opinions of the posters. Libelous or obscene comments will be removed.
 
 

 

 

Add a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Auto-login on future visits

Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password?

 

Letters

‘The moral voice of the Senate’

Joe Lieberman is the moral voice of the Senate and former Democratic vice presidential nominee. His comments about Sen. Obama at the NORPAC fund-raiser for Sen. McCain are not that one needs military experience to be president. Rather, Sen. Lieberman acknowledged that Sen. Obama was very talented, but said that he lacked the background and experience to assume the highest office in the land. Sen. Lieberman will likely lose his chairmanship of the Senate Homeland Security Committee and his seniority in the Democratic caucus due to his support of Sen. McCain. That Sen. Lieberman would cross party lines to endorse John McCain says volumes about the merit of both leaders. This crossing of the aisle is a measure of character where one acts according to the belief that his candidate of choice, regardless of party affiliation, is most fit for the position. Whether one agrees with Sen. Lieberman is beside the point. His willingness to put his career and Senate standing in jeopardy for the benefit of his county should be acknowledged and admired.

Ben Chouake, President, NORPAC, Englewood

 

Letters

Blessings of a broken heart

In Sherrie Mandel’s play "The Blessings of a Broken Heart," shown at the JCC [last] Monday night, the actress Lisa Robins portrays Sherrie Mandel, whose son Kobi was brutally murdered in a terrorist attack seven years ago. Robins, the actress portraying Sherrie, shares also her own cry in the play, because she too (as she said in answer to a question after the play) "has so much to cry about."

For me, that line sums up the message of the play. The truth is that no matter how fortunate we are, everybody has something to cry about. As a generation separated, just barely, from the horrors of the Holocaust, we can take a lesson from the Mandels and share our personal grief and sorrow rather than repress and go about our lives — the style adopted by our parents.

 

Letters

‘No better catcher’

I just happened to peruse the article on Jews loving baseball, which asked the question whether there was a Jewish Major League catcher. As a New York Giants fan back in the 1940s, I can tell the answer is a resounding yes. There was no better catcher than Harry Danning of the late great New York Giants. He lived during the season at Hudson View Gardens in Washington Heights and was always available to throw a ball around with the neighborhood kids.

Norm Solon, Bluffton, S.C.

 

RECENTLYADDED

Anna Baltzer, Jewish defamer of Israel

In 1505, a Moravian Jew named Joseph Pfefferkorn renounced his faith and undertook a campaign to get the Talmud banned by claiming it blasphemed Christianity. Pfefferkorn was unschooled and a criminal, but that didn’t stop the Dominicans in Cologne, who at the time were eager to cast aspersions on the Jews, from employing him. They recognized the value of a Jew accusing other Jews.

The practice of finding Jews to bear false witness against other Jews has been repeated in many venues. Today, in America, some mainline Protestant churches have eagerly adopted this practice in an effort to demonize Israel. In November, the Wyoming Presbyterian church in Millburn, N,J., invited Jewish anti-Israel activist Anna Baltzer to speak and present her slide show alleging Israeli crimes against the Palestinians.

 

An open letter to Israel’s Ambassador Michael Oren

As founders and members of the Women of the Wall, Jerusalem, and the International Committee for the Women of the Wall, we turn to you out of concern for Israel as well as our cause.

Those of us who knew you as a professor or community member in the past want to believe that you had no part in drafting the message issued by the embassy in response to the thousands of e-mails that we and our supporters sent following the arrest in November of Nofrat Frenkel for the “crime” of wearing a tallit at the Kotel, carrying a sefer Torah, and letting her voice be heard, and the subsequent fingerprinting and interrogation of Anat Hoffman for the same “crimes.”

 

An open letter to Rabbi Shmuley Boteach

Dear Rabbi Boteach,

I am disturbed and offended by your campaign to purchase the Libyan mission’s property adjacent to your home in Englewood. While I join you in support of your condemnation of the Libyan government, its policies toward Israel, and its failure to take moral responsibility for the deaths of hundreds of innocent Americans, I fail to understand why you refuse to abide by the talmudic principle “Dina Malchuta Dina,” the law of the land in which we live must be observed by Jews. As Rep. Steve Rothman explained in a very detailed statement in response to your initial demand that the Libyans be forced to leave the property they own in Englewood, the issue of the legitimacy of their purchase and continued ownership has been adjudicated. Whether we like it or not, the United States courts have determined that they have the right to own that property.

 

 

S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28