Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter

 
font size: +
 

With friends like these…

 
 
 

Glenn Beck, the Fox commentator, held a big rally on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial on Saturday and if you are not a Christian, you should be very, very afraid.

Of course, that is not the conventional wisdom in some Jewish circles. If a person supports tuition vouchers for private schools on the one hand and opposes any territorial concessions by Israel to the Palestinians on the other, that person is cheered, not feared. It is a dangerously myopic view.

John Hagee, the Texas pastor who in 2006 founded Christians United for Israel, is the perfect example. Hagee wins praise time and again from Jewish leaders here and in Israel for demanding that the United States “stop putting pressure on the nation of Israel for a no-growth policy in Judea and Samaria.”

Keepin the Faith

What Jewish leaders prefer to ignore is why Hagee holds such views. To him, Jewish control of the “Holy Land” is an essential prerequisite for that moment in the not-too-distant future when we Christ-killers will be given one last chance to recognize our transgression and abandon our Judaism. Here, for example, is what this “friend of the Jews” said on National Public Radio’s “Fresh Air with Terry Gross” just a few days before Rosh HaShanah in 2006:

“Now, when it comes to the Jewish people, [the prophet] Zechariah very clearly says that they are not going to believe that Jesus Christ is the Messiah until they see him. Zechariah says in the 14th chapter ‘and when they,’ the Jewish people, ‘see him whom they have pierced’ — and the word pierced there actually refers to his rib and side — ‘when they see him whom they have pierced, they will weep as one weeps for his only son for a period of one week.’ They’re simply not going to believe he is the Messiah until they actually see him, and that’s at the Second Coming. Then, at that point in time, there is the judgment of the nations in which all nations are judged for the way in which they have treated the nation of Israel and the Jewish people, and the Jewish people are front and center in the kingdom of God that will be an eternal kingdom.”

That is, we are “front and center in the kingdom of God” if we abandon our faith and accept Christianity. Hagee is entitled to his vision of the future, but we should be alert enough to understand the words he uses to describe it. The Jews killed Christ. In the end of days, when the Jews see his awful wounds, they will cry out in mourning for the evil they did to him and to the world. This is what Hagee is saying.

As for what “Zechariah says in the 14th chapter,” Hagee surely meant Zechariah 12:10, which has nothing to do with Jesus or with the Jews piercing anyone; on the contrary, it is we who are martyred for protecting Jerusalem. (Hagee is not responsible for this distortion of Zechariah; it is a long-cherished Christian teaching.)

Hagee also has a twisted notion of the role the Nazis played in Jewish history, in keeping with his interpretation of another one of the Bible’s verses, Jeremiah 16:15-16.

Referring to the Jews, God says, “I will bring them back to their land, which I gave to their fathers. Behold, I am sending for many fishermen — declares the Lord — and they shall haul them out; and after that I will send for many hunters, and they shall hunt them out of every mountain and out of every hill, and out of the clefts of the rocks.”

“First, God sent the fishermen to Israel,” Hagee writes in his book “Jerusalem Countdown: A Warning to the World.” The fishermen “were the Zionists, men like Theodor Herzl who called ... the sons and daughters of Abraham home.”

When we failed to hear the Zionist message, “God then sent the hunters,” wrote Hagee, referring to the Nazi horde. The “force and fear of Hitler’s Nazis drove the Jewish people back to the only home God ever intended for the Jews to have — Israel.... I am stricken with awe and wonder at His boundless love for Israel and the Jewish people and His divine determination that the promise He gave Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob become reality.”

I am stricken with awe and wonder at the stupidity of that statement, as well as its insensitivity and its seeming ignorance of where the Nazis actually sent the Jewish people. I am more stricken, however, by the fact that no one calls Hagee to task for saying that Israel is “the only home God ever intended for the Jews to have,” by which he also means that Jews do not belong in this country or any other outside Israel. If this is the kind of person we laud, God help us.

Hagee was a prominent member of Saturday’s Glenn Beck-led cast, which did include a rabbi, and which did have Beck saying such inclusive-sounding things as “go to your churches, synagogues, and mosques.”

Not Beck and not Hagee, however, could disguise the real intent of the day. “Something beyond imagination is happening,” Beck told the cheering throng. “America today begins to turn back to God.”

Beck meant the Christian view of God. “Pray on your knees,” he exhorted the crowd, something Jews, at least, do not do, as he well knows.

Ironically, which Christian view of God is the subject of debate in Christian circles, since Beck himself is a convert to Mormonism, which most Christians consider a heretical cult.

What matters, though, is not which Christian view, but that it is a Christian view. Beck and Hagee and their ilk believe that America was founded on Christian values; in truth, it was founded more on values found in the Torah than anywhere else. They believe that America is a Christian nation; in truth, the founding fathers went to great lengths to make it the welcoming home of people of all faiths and even of those who profess no faith at all.

Beck brought a Christian army to Washington on Saturday, and its goal is to cleanse America of any thoughts and ideals he and Hagee and their kind consider not authentically Christian.

When Mahmoud Abbas says one thing in English and another in Arabic, we hold up the Arabic statements as his true intent. When the so-called Christian Zionists say one thing to our faces and another behind our backs, we choose to ignore those statements or to dismiss them.

We do this at our peril.

Shammai Engelmayer
Shammai Engelmayer is rabbi of the Conservative synagogue Temple Israel Community Center in Cliffside Park and an instructor in the UJA-Federation-sponsored Florence Melton Adult Mini-School of the Hebrew University. He is the editor of Judaism: A Journal of Jewish Life and Thought.
Disclaimer
The views in opinion pieces and letters do not necessarily reflect the views of The Jewish Standard. The comments posted on this Website are solely the opinions of the posters. Libelous or obscene comments will be removed.
 
 
 
Rosalie Greenberg posted 06 Sep 2010 at 12:55 AM

The “Restoring Honor” rally was not about the Rev. John Hagee.  The “real intent of the day” was that Americans of all religions should turn to their faith in G-d to restore the values and principles that made us great.  Glenn Beck’s real intent was not to return us to the Christian view of G-d.  It was to return us to “Faith, Hope and Charity,” .to principles and morals.  Glenn Beck’s so called “Christian army” included 2,000 clergymen in attendance from ALL faiths at the Kennedy Center on Friday night, before the rally the next day and 240 clergy from different races and religions at the rally joining the events’ speakers on stage before its closing statements.

Englemayer states “and if you are not a Christian you should be very, very afraid.”  Glenn Beck is a libertarian.  He is against big government.  He believes in “We the people,” the Constitution, the founding fathers and freedom of religion.  There is nothing to fear from him.  This is who he is.  He does not say “one thing to our face and another behind our backs.”

My husband and I were privileged to be in attendance at the 8/28 Rally to Restore Honor.  Seeing is believing.  Here is the link to C-Span’s full coverage of the rally. 

http://www.c-span.org/Watch/Media/2010/08/28/HP/A/37551/Restoring+Honor+Rally.aspx

Sincerely,

Rosalie Greenberg
Teaneck, NJ

Missy posted 06 Sep 2010 at 05:40 PM

I agree with Rosalie. She was succinct and accurate.

Rather I pose this question to those all so concerned about Glenn Beck…..wake up and smell the Sharia law coming. 

No one is outing Sharia law as the ultimate of oppression upon women; ALL the feminists have yet to stand up and denounce it.  Instead they are afraid like they were afraid before WWII, yet there will be a time when all must stand together against Sharia law which is in violation of our Constitution. 

Women are stoned, beheaded and treated like possessions and second class citizens….so rise above the petty comments about Glenn Beck and get informed about Sharia law and how inch by inch they intend to bring it to America.  On the cover of time magazine a woman was shown with her nose and ears cut off - did you hear the outrage…..funny, neither did I !

What about the civil liberties and rights of the people of China….now that Hillary is the Secretary of State, I hear nothing about that anymore…Is it because we owe China so much money?  You tell me.

My hope is that Americans will never stand for that but I didn’t think we would be where we are now in America either…..

This is off the article to be sure, but why doesn’t anyone write about it?

HARRY posted 06 Sep 2010 at 06:39 PM

Rabbi Shammai Engelmayer essentially called Pastor John Hagee our enemy.  He concluded his article with “When the so-called Christian Zionists say one thing to our faces and another behind our backs, we choose to ignore those statements or to dismiss them.  We do this at our peril.”  So, let us read what the villainous Hagee told his people in a recent address at the fifth annual Christians United for Israel: 

“At this difficult juncture in our history, permit me to say something to you straight from the heart. Please know that what I say now is a sentiment shared by millions of Christians across America and around the world.

Today, in the world of freedom, the proudest boast is “Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.”

All free men, wherever they may live, are citizens of Israel. Therefore, as a free man, I take pride in the words Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When international bodies ignore the world’s genocides, massacres, and racism to attack Israel, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When college professors teach lies about Israel and students loudly call for Israel’s destruction, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When hateful protesters try to shout you down, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When flotillas filled with militants seek to turn Gaza into an Iranian port, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When the world condemns Israel for defending its citizens from thousands of missile and mortar attacks, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When terrorists threaten to kill Israelis, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When madmen threaten to destroy Israel, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

When Israel’s allies grow weary of fighting tyranny and oppression and seek an easy out that ultimately brings danger closer to our own door, we proudly proclaim:

Ani Yisraeli - I am an Israeli.

Israel and America share the same love of freedom.

Israel and America share the same passion for democracy.

Israel and America share the same Judeo-Christian values.

Israel and America share the same love of life.

Israel and America share the same enemies.

Israel’s enemies are our enemies.

Israel’s fight is our fight.”

 
Add a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Auto-login on future visits

Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password?

 

Rise of our own radical right

Three forms of religious extremism confronted me recently. The first occured in England, when I lectured at Limmud, a studies conference attended by fully one percent of all Jews in Britain. Every Jewish group was represented — except for the Orthodox rabbinate, which boycotted the event because of the presence of Reform and Conservative (Masorti) rabbis.

The second and more insidious example of frightening religious intolerance hit me as I landed in Israel a few days later for the press launch of my book “Kosher Jesus.” I discovered a country up in arms because a small group of charedim spat at and cursed an Orthodox eight-year-old girl for her “immodest” dress (she was wearing a knee-length skirt with shoulders and elbows covered), and because a charedi man called a female Israeli soldier a “whore” for refusing to move to the back of a bus (he was arrested).

 

 

A rabbi’s ban

By right, I ought to thank Rabbi Immanuel Schochet for banning my book “Kosher Jesus,” because doing so further propelled it up the international bestseller lists, even in pre-publication. Bizarrely calling his own views “authoritative,” Schochet declared my book to be heresy, banned anyone from reading it, banned me from speaking about it, banned others from inviting me to speak about it, and refused to offer a single reason or explanation as to why.

This dictatorial edict follows a growing wave of religious fanaticism hitting the world Jewish community all at once with right-wing reactionaries seeking to impose a primitive dogmatism on those who believe Judaism can be Orthodox yet informed, Torah-based yet educated, true to halachic sources yet fearless in the marketplace of ideas. The Jewish community is not Iran and its rabbis are not the Revolutionary Guard. Let the ayatollahs burn books and condemn authors. Jews are the people of the book, not the people who ban books. We have all too much experience with the medieval practice of outlawing books. Schochet’s attack deserves to be pasted on a wall of Meah Shearim, not sent by mail, as it was, to Chabad emissaries around the world.

 

 

Stunning stability

In 1948, two social scientists published the first scholarly study of religious group voting patterns in the United States. According to the authors, Catholics, Jews, and Baptists identified as Democrats by margins of two to one or better. Five denominations that we would classify as mainline Protestants were Republican by equally lopsided ratios. Although the authors did not report on black Protestants, most of whom were still forbidden to vote by Jim Crow laws, data collected at the time showed African-Americans evenly split in loyalty between the two parties.

Sixty years later, the exit polls from 2008 show that almost nothing is the same. Baptists have swung across the spectrum; they and their fellow Evangelical Protestants now constitute the single most pro-Republican religious bloc. Catholics and African-Americans have traded places, the former now divided almost evenly between Democrats and Republicans, and the latter overwhelmingly favoring Democratic candidates. Once the core of the Republican vote, the shrinking body of mainline Protestants increasingly sits out elections or, while still identifying as Republican, tends to favor Democrats by small margins.

 

 

RECENTLYADDED

A values-voice for Congress?

Let me state this clearly. Despite some news reports, I am not a candidate for Congress in New Jersey’s Ninth Congreessional District. I am considering becoming a candidate, however, and I so informed the Bergen County Republican Organization (BCPO). People considering becoming candidated had until Jan. 31 to inform the BCPO of their interest; otherwise, they could not be considered for the party’s nomination (although they could run in a primary).

 

 

Choosing trees over love

My column this week is adapted from an earlier version. Sometimes, what you have already written about a subject or issue is worth repeating rather than rewriting.

This Wednesday, Feb. 8, is Tu Bi-Sh’vat, aka the New Year for Trees, Judaism’s millennia-old “Earth Day.” Less than a week later comes Feb. 14, aka Valentine’s Day; Saint Valentine’s Day, to be precise.

It is a safe — and sad — bet that more Jews will celebrate the former than the latter. As one person pointedly explained to me, Valentine’s Day “is an American holiday that celebrates love.” The inference, of course, is that Judaism has no such glorious day on its calendar.

 

 

A rabbi’s ban

By right, I ought to thank Rabbi Immanuel Schochet for banning my book “Kosher Jesus,” because doing so further propelled it up the international bestseller lists, even in pre-publication. Bizarrely calling his own views “authoritative,” Schochet declared my book to be heresy, banned anyone from reading it, banned me from speaking about it, banned others from inviting me to speak about it, and refused to offer a single reason or explanation as to why.

This dictatorial edict follows a growing wave of religious fanaticism hitting the world Jewish community all at once with right-wing reactionaries seeking to impose a primitive dogmatism on those who believe Judaism can be Orthodox yet informed, Torah-based yet educated, true to halachic sources yet fearless in the marketplace of ideas. The Jewish community is not Iran and its rabbis are not the Revolutionary Guard. Let the ayatollahs burn books and condemn authors. Jews are the people of the book, not the people who ban books. We have all too much experience with the medieval practice of outlawing books. Schochet’s attack deserves to be pasted on a wall of Meah Shearim, not sent by mail, as it was, to Chabad emissaries around the world.

 

 
 
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29