Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter

 
font size: +
 

No good deed goes unpunished

Some places to learn more about Kasztner

 
 
 
 

More on: No good deed goes unpunished

 
 
 

The woman who made the film

Gaylen Ross is an award-winning producer and director with her own company, GR Films. She earned her Emmy for her film “Blood Money: Switzerland’s Nazi Gold,” and has made films about Manhattan’s Diamond Center and Russian mail-order brides. She is presenting the American debut of the controversial “Killing Kasztner” in New York City.

Ross first found out about Kasztner when she did the film on the Swiss banks and met a woman who had been a passenger on the train.

 
 

A controversy revisited

Until a few years ago, when people asked me about my Holocaust survivor parents, I would say that my mother, Peska Friedman, survived as a footnote in history. She was a Polish escapee from the Warsaw Ghetto who managed to get on a Hungarian train known as the Kasztner Transport. Named for Reszó/Rudolph/Israel Kasztner, the Hungarian Zionist leader and liaison to the Jewish Agency (the Sachnut), the train left Nazi territory — Budapest — in June 1944 for freedom in Palestine, via Switzerland. It was hardly an uneventful trip. Most of the passengers were held hostage in Bergen-Belsen for six months before they were released near St. Gallen, Switzerland. In the end, 1,684 people were saved, and most historians agree that the negotiations landed approximately 18,000 others in labor camps in Austria — where they were held as potential bargaining chips with the Allies instead of being deported to Auschwitz.

 
 
 
 
 
Mordechai Levy posted 18 Oct 2009 at 01:03 PM

B’SD
Katner is NO Hero !


          There is nothing heroic about Kastner who refused to save
the hundreds of thousands of Jews in Hungary choosing instead to
rescue his friends and family ! At that very time that Kastner collaborated
with the Nazi murder machine a different group of real heroes was trying to
rescuse them the Irgun that set up an operation called Af Al Pi organized by Zev
Jabotinky and Ben _Hecht to smuggle huge numbers of Jews out on boats and bring them
to pre-state Israel.Of course these Irgun boys risked arrest at the hands of the British
government for violating a Britsh law called the White Paper used to keep Auschwitz fleeing
Jews from getting into Israel.At the time both Kastner and Ben Gurion condemned the life saving
rescue operations because it “violated British law. Now compare the act of treachery of letting
nad helping the Nazis murder other Jews which is what Kastner did, with the noble action of the
Orhodox Rabbis and Torah Sages (in cooperation with the Irgun) who heroically marched on the
White House in 1943 to demand that Pres Roosevelt rescuse all of the Jews facing being
murdered ! The Torah Sages were the heroes and Kastner is not !

 
Add a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Auto-login on future visits

Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password?

 

In balance, in harmony

Agnes Adler is a little pixie of a thing with a musical Hungarian accent. As she and her husband David walk into a room, she tells him to smile, to say hello, not to be a grump, and he lovingly responds, “Yes, Mammi, whatever you say.” He is wont to stay in the background, however, as an invisible flying buttress, supporting her in artistic endeavors and much more, while also creating his own massive sculptures.

David stands a full head taller than his wife, continues to smile the smile of the gentlemen chauvinists of his generation. He and Aggie love to sharpen their blades on their wit and humor. She complains, “I have to do everything and he expects me to wait on him hand and foot. Men! Impossible!”

 

Haiti: Two years later

‘When all else is broken, human dignity must stand whole’

Two years after the earthquake that devastated Haiti, medical students at Quisqueya University earlier this month took part in the island nation’s first “White Coat Ceremony,” marking the commitment of medical students there to providing compassionate, patient-based care.

This symbolic ritual for future doctors, now common at U.S. and Israeli medical schools, was introduced in 1993 by the Englewood Cliffs-based Arnold P. Gold Foundation. It has since spread to 18 countries, including Afghanistan, Japan, and now Haiti, thanks to the efforts of Tenafly resident Dr. Galit M. Sacajiu.

“Some of you may be asking yourselves, when medical school buildings and operating rooms have yet to be rebuilt and a single medical textbook is a luxury, when we have no laboratories, and so many of our brothers and sisters still live in makeshift homes, why invest in an event such as this ceremony of humanism in medicine?” asked Sacajiu, in her remarks at the Jan. 16 ceremony.

 

Love and hate in Bergen County

Communal meeting, interfaith gathering follow in Rutherford bombing’s wake

With the Jewish communities of Bergen County on heightened alert, some 200 religious and community leaders gathered on Jan. 12 to discuss the recent string of anti-Semitic incidents in the county with law enforcement and government officials.

The meeting followed by one day the most recent, and most serious, attack — a firebombing that could have claimed the lives of eight people. The incident targeted the old Queen Anne building in Rutherford that houses Orthodox Congregation Beth El, as well as the home of its rabbi and his family. Five of the eight potential victims were children.

 

RECENTLYADDED

Iran threat

Will March 5 be D(ecision) Day?

WASHINGTON – March 5 is shaping up to be a crucial day in the effort to rein in Iran’s nuclear program.

In Vienna, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) will convene to consider its inspectors’ latest report on Iran’s nuclear program. The last such report came closer than ever to indicting the Iranian regime for making weapons, and it helped spur stronger international sanctions against Tehran.

Several hours later, in Washington, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu will deliver a speech to an American Israel Public Affairs policy conference about what should happen next with Iran. Either before or after the AIPAC meeting, Netanyahu likely will meet with President Barack Obama to discuss Iran options.

 

Iran threat

After a string of foiled plots...

WASHINGTON – When America’s top intelligence official said that Iran’s regime is considering attacks on U.S. soil, he cited a single incident and qualified the assessment with a “probably.”

Intelligence and law enforcement experts, however, say that the Jan. 31 warning by the director of national intelligence, James Clapper, was likely based on more than the evidence he cited.

“I would be surprised to learn a statement like that was not backed up by intelligence,” said Mark Dubowitz, executive director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies.

 

Iran threat

Locally, fear not but be alert

News reports notwithstanding, “There is no indication that there are any specific and/or imminent threats to Jewish communities in the U.S. at this time as a result of recent events,” according to an alert received this week by the Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC) of the Jewish Federation of Northern New Jersey. Nevertheless, the alert said, that could change “should military action break out in the Middle East in coming months.”

An open attack on Iran is only one “trigger” that could raise the threat level, the alert said. “Increased pressure from sanctions, continued perceived threats from Israel, the United States, and others, sabotage against nuclear facilities, and continued alleged assassinations of Iranian nuclear scientists” could also bring about an Iranian response aimed at Jewish or Israeli targets in the West, especially the United States.

 
 
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29