Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter

 
font size: +
 

Teaching the Shoah

Passaic students learn about prejudice at D.C. museum

 
 
 
Passaic students learn about prejudice at D.C. museum
image
Passaic middle school students visit Washington, D.C.

As a language arts teacher at the Lincoln Middle School in Passaic, Sharon Surloff realized that her eighth-grade students, mostly black or Latino, had grown up knowing little, if anything, about the Holocaust.

Projects to remedy this were already under way. In her class, the teenagers had already studied Elie Wiesel’s “Night” and had been deeply moved, she said. She was also engaging them in discussions, bringing in survivors, taking field trips, and doing Holocaust-related projects.

Something was missing, however.

“As a teacher, I know that providing students with an educational opportunity that will touch them emotionally is the most promising way to turn a school lesson into a life-changing experience,” noted Surloff, who grew up in Fair Lawn.

The missing ingredient, she decided, was a trip to the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C. To do that, however, she needed the funds.

“I wrote a grant letter and did research in the public library to find foundations,” she said. “My mother [Fair Lawn resident Evelyn Surloff] helped me with the leg work, and we found some donors.”

image
Sharon Surloff

While some of those donors have chosen to remain anonymous, one — whose husband was killed on 9/11 and who is looking for worthy projects to fund in his name — actually sought out Surloff and offered to help. The teacher is also receiving financial assistance from the Warren and Mitzi Eisenberg Family Foundation.

“It is unfortunate… that the children in our poorest communities have little exposure to the history of intolerance of the Jews in Europe, and even less of the relevance of that experience to their own situation,” Surloff wrote to potential donors. “It is my hope that by providing this experience, we will fill that gap in their knowledge and help to reduce the intolerance we see today in our local minority communities and our society at large.”

For several years, Surloff took her students to the Museum of Jewish Heritage in New York City. Thanks to a grant from the museum, students did not have to pay for their transportation, admission, tour guides, or the interns who come to the school to meet with them both before and after their field trip.

She said, however, that her students were “primed and eager for the logical extension of their Holocaust learning.”

This year, Surloff will be making the Washington trip for the fifth time. For her students, she said, the visit is an “eye-opening” experience.

For one thing, many have never been outside Passaic.

“I have never gone that far from home before,” wrote one student. “My family is from Mexico and we are poor, we struggle to buy the things we need, so I feel extremely lucky to have been able to go.”

That same student was deeply moved by the Holocaust Museum.

“How could the Nazis hate so much that they would kill, and in some cases, torture children?” he asked. “Learning about the Holocaust was interesting, but seeing the documentation in the museum made it really come to life in a way that reading a book can’t really do.”

“At the end of the museum exhibits, there was an opportunity for us to take an oath against genocide,” he added. “I signed my name to the oath and I am going to start researching to see what I can do to stop modern-day genocide. I may be only one person, but maybe I can make a difference.”

“I just couldn’t hold back my tears as I became witness to the horrors that the Nazis committed against the Jews,” wrote another student, who said it was an “honor” to listen to a survivor at the museum telling her story. “I took a moment to thank her for letting me hear her story and [told her] how blessed I felt.”

Another student wrote of his joy at seeing the nation’s capital.

“I am the first generation in my family to be born in the United States, so it meant a lot to me to go and see the White House. To me, the White House represents everything about America because it is a symbol of the president and the freedom that this country has to offer. I ran right up to it and held onto the gates.”

“One of the most important things I learned from [my teacher] is to stand up for what I believe in, especially when I see something that I think is wrong,” noted the same student. “I never want to be the person who does nothing. I am better than that.”

Surloff said it was her students’ interest and curiosity that inspired her to pursue this project.

“They had a thirst to know more,” she said. “It came from them, not from me. The best teachers let their students guide the instruction. It turned into something bigger than I thought it would be.”

She has seen some “beautiful things” come out of the Washington trips, she said.

“The first year we were there we told the students they had to be dressed appropriately and act appropriately,” she recalled. “The students were looking at something and a student from another school pushed past us. One of my students turned to me and said, ‘How could somebody come to this museum and push someone around like that?’”

A second incident occurred after her students were treated badly during a recreational activity.

“They were so dejected by this,” she said, noting that students from another school had addressed them using racial slurs.

“Someone should take them to the Holocaust Museum,” said one of her students. “They need to learn something about racism and bias.”

 

More on: Teaching the Shoah

 
 
 

In Fair Lawn, Butterfly Project remembers the children

Fair Lawn English teacher Pam Haug was excited to learn this year that class time for her Literature Connections course had been expanded from seven to eight periods.

“It’s devoted to novels and longer pieces, and we can do more with them,” she said, explaining that she and other Thomas Jefferson Middle School eighth-grade teachers immediately set out to find new materials to add to the curriculum.

“We always read ‘The Diary of Anne Frank,’” she said. “The [Fair Lawn] Memorial Middle School told us they have ‘I Never Saw Another Butterfly,’ so we wanted to find a way to incorporate that, as well.”

 
 
 
 
 
Rosa Sirota posted 23 Dec 2011 at 12:12 PM

I was very moved by your article regarding the Passaic students’ trip to Washinton to visit the Holocaust Museum.  Being a teacher, I can’t imagine a better way of exposing students to such a tragic, yet important, part of history.  I happen to be one of the survivors who spoke to both Ms. Surloff’s class in Passaaic and to all the eigth graders in the Thomas Jefferson Middle School in Fair Lawn, which was organized by Ms. Haugh.

The “thank you” letters I received confirm the value and the need for Holocaust education, and since none of the survivors are young and will be able to speak much longer, it is even more effective when students hear from personal experience.

 
Add a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Auto-login on future visits

Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password?

 

‘Joyful, jubilant,’ and sorely missed

A young woman’s death shakes North Jersey communities

On April 29, 22-year-old Stephanie Prezant of Haworth lost her life in a rock-climbing accident in upstate New York. While the community, however, is mourning the loss of this beloved young woman — whose safety equipment failed while climbing the Trapps Cliff area of the Mohonk Preserve — they also are remembering the joy she brought to others.

“She was very funny, always trying to make people laugh,” said longtime friend Anna Kaminsky, from Englewood Cliffs. “I’m glad that at the funeral, people were able to capture that.”

Conducted by Rabbi Mordecai Shain, executive director of Lubavitch on the Palisades, the funeral was held on May 1 at the Kaplen JCC on the Palisades.

 

He saw a need

Outdoor sanctuary earns Ben Sagerman an Eagle Badge

If leadership means to see a problem where no one else does, and then take the initiative to solve it, Ben Sagerman is definitely a leader.

The 17-year-old high school junior loved the experience of outdoor prayer he experienced at the Union for Reform Judaism’s Camp Eisner — and wanted to make that experience possible for his fellow congregants at Temple Avodat Shalom in River Edge.

So he built an outdoor sanctuary, a small ampitheater, in an empty space on Avodat Shalom’s property.

 

Tending to the liberators

March of Living honors vets, with N.J. doctor in tow

Englewood resident Dr. David Arbit has spent much of his adult life hearing about the Shoah.

“My father-in-law is a survivor,” says the physician, who practices in Fair Lawn. “At every bar- or bat mitzvah, he would get up and speak about his experiences.”

Now, however, Arbit can add many more firsthand accounts to those he already knows. As the physician designated by the March of the Living program to accompany this year’s honorees — some 16 former U.S. servicemen who were among the first to arrive at Europe’s many concentration camps during World War II — the doctor says he now has both new information and detailed verification of his father-in-law’s stories.

 

RECENTLYADDED

Fourth synagogue targeted

Latest attack was most dangerous yet

A firebomb attack on a synagogue in Rutherford is being investigated as an attempted homicide and a hate crime, Bergen County Prosecutor John Molinelli announced on Wednesday.

“You’re looking at 40 to 50 years in prison,” said Molinelli, addressing the “person or persons who are doing this act” at a Wednesday afternoon press conference.

“Turn yourself in and end this now,” he said. “We will ultimately solve this crime and make arrests.”

Around 4:30 a.m. Wednesday morning, several Molotov cocktails were thrown at Congregation Beth El, an Orthodox synagogue on a quiet residential street in Rutherford. One entered the second floor bedroom of the congregation’s rabbi, Nosson Schuman, and ignited his bedspread.

 

U.S. Senate unanimously calls on U.N. to rescind Goldstone

WASHINGTON – The U.S. Senate unanimously approved a resolution calling on the United Nations to rescind the Goldstone report. Sens. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) and James Risch (R-Idaho) initiated the resolution last week after Richard Goldstone, a South African judge, retracted a key conclusion of the U.N. report he helped author on the 2009 Gaza war -- that Israel had targeted civilians as a policy.
 

Israeli dignitary welcomed by NJ State Senate March 21

Senate President Extends Invitation to Ido Aharoni, Consul General of Israel in NY

Union, N.J. (March 18, 2011) – In a gesture of friendship and cooperation, Senate President Stephen Sweeney has invited Ido Aharoni, Consul General of Israel in NY to appear before the upper body of the legislature at the Senate Chamber on Monday March 21, 2011 at 2 p.m. Aharoni will make a formal presentation to the State Senate prior to the voting session.

 
 
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31